 |
| Fordow Nuclear Plant, Iran |
Some Comments about the Operation
As I have discussed previously, it is hard to view this as an "attack" or an "aggression" by Israel. Since October 7, 2023, Israel has been fighting a multi-front war with Iran and its proxies, which was all initiated by Iran. Iran was responsible for funding and training Hamas and Hezbollah, for arming the Houthis and for supporting other terroristic attacks against Israel worldwide. All while threatening that it was finally about to destroy Israel. In context, Israel's operation that started on June 13th, 2025 (6-13 for those who like to think about this biblically - being the total number of mitzvoth according to Jewish tradition) is really a counterattack in response the multi-front war initiated by Iran including Iran's own ballistic missile attacks against Israel.
There was a significant indication that Iran was racing towards rolling out a nuclear bomb - and its stated intention was to use it. Since Israel's attack, various international sources have confirmed that this was the case. So the perceived urgency on the part of Israel - was that Iran was getting "too close for comfort" to using a nuclear weapon against Israel - something Israel couldn't wait for.
The initial stage of this counterattack was carried out by Israel with near perfection, according to most reports and was historic, dramatic and brilliantly effective.
As you know from various reports, more than 30 top Iranian commanders, including the head of the Air Force, the head of the Army and the head of the ballistic missile program, were all killed on the first night of the operation. This apparently included the use of Mossad agents and AI to lure various Iranian senior officers into a mass gathering, at which they were attacked and killed. Together with this, Israel established air superiority and has carried out attacks on Iranian military targets, nuclear sites, missile launch sites and other equipment. Many Iranian nuclear scientists have also been killed.
Iranian Response
Since June 13th, Iran's primary response has been to launch ballistic missiles, drones and other missiles at Israel. According to an article in the Jerusalem Post written moments ago, Iran has launched approximately 500 ballistic missiles at Israel since June 13th and close to 500 drones. Most of these missiles and almost all of the drones have been intercepted. However, a significant number have hit Israel. Most of these missiles have targeted civilian targets. Among the hardest hit locations have been the Soroka Hospital in Beersheva, the Rambam hospital in Haifa, a mosque (the Al-Jarina Mosque) in Haifa and several residential buildings in Ramat Gan, Bat Yam, Rishon L'Tzion, Nes Ziona and other places. A large research facility was destroyed at the Weizmann Institute in Rehovot, much of which housed advanced cancer research facilities. More than 25 Israelis have been killed, several hundred people have been injured (it may be over a thousand at this point) and more than 25,000 property damage claims have been filed by Israelis with the Israeli government. (The Israeli government covers a significant amount of the property damage in these circumstances). Unlike the Hamas-controlled hospitals in Gaza, the Israeli hospitals did not house any military bases, missiles or army equipment. Iran's primary attacks have been against civilians.
On Saturday June 21, the Iranians began using additional types of missiles including missiles that they have purchased from North Korea - that can change directions and evade the U.S. THAAD systems and the Israeli anti-ballistic missile systems - at least some of the time. Some of these missiles have included Iran's "Haj Qasem" missiles which are armed with cluster bombs and massive warheads. At least two or three of these have landed in Israel and caused massive damage. The deadliest missile used so far by Iran is the Hwasong 10 from North Korea - named the Khorramshahr by Iran. This is apparently the missile that hit the Soroka Hospital last week. It carries more than 1,500 kilograms of explosives.
Although Israel has been defending against these missile attacks - with the help of the U.S., Jordan and other regional allies, some of these missiles have still been getting through and causing quite a bit of damage. Israel has been attacking missile storage sites, launching equipment and other targets, but it is quite likely that Iran still has significant capacity to cause severe damage with various types of ballistic missiles.
Israel has an alert system in place and usually have 10-13 minutes to get to the nearest bomb shelter (or in-house "safe room") if the missiles are coming from Iran or Yemen, and less time if they are coming from Lebanon. Since 1991, Israeli buildings are all built with at least one thick-walled concrete room per floor (or per unit) with a heavy metal door - than can withstand shrapnel, hits to other parts of the building and other types of attacks. These safe rooms cannot withstand direct hits. But the vast majority of Israelis who have been in safe rooms when their buildings have been hit - or when nearby buildings have been hit - have suffered only minor injuries.
I should note that Iran has hit other targets, including an Oil Refinery in Haifa and some targets about which details have not been released or published. Still it is apparent that the vast majority of targets have been civilian.
The U.S Entry
As you may know, according to many different world reports, only the U.S. has the type of bunker busting bombs that would be necessary to destroy some of the Iranian nuclear facilities - including the Fordow nuclear plant which was 90 metres below ground in central Iran. Fordow has or had more than 3,000 centrifuges and was being used to enrich uranium to near-bomb grade of close to 90% U-235.
President Trump said in a statement earlier today that the Fordow plant has been "obliterated." I hope that he is right - but I am not sure that the U.S. has the full damage assessment yet. Reports are that Iran has already produced approximately 500 kilograms of near weapons-grade uranium and the Iranians claim that this uranium was moved to a secret location before the U.S. attacks.
In my view, it is more likely than not that this whole operation was jointly planned with the Israelis from the outset. It seems unlikely to me that Israel would have embarked on an operation against Iran, on this scale, while knowing that it could not destroy the Fordow plant itself.
President Trump was under intense pressure from different elements of his party. The "hawks," including Lindsay Graham and others were pushing Trump to "seize the moment" and help Israel destroy the nuclear plants. In their view, it was a necessary step not only to protect Israel - but to protect the whole world - including, in particular, U.S interests in the region, from a nuclear armed Iran. The evangelical wing, including ambassador Mike Huckabee, were pushing Trump to act because it was "God's will." Weighed against this, Trump was getting an earful from "isolationists" and anti-Israeli voices including Tucker Carlson, Steve Bannon and Marjorie Green. In the end, he sided, as we know with the hawks and evangelicals - and with the Israeli right. To the extent that one might wonder about a particular angle by considering the voices who are advocating it - it seems that any rational decision maker - when faced with a unified position coming from Tucker Carlson, Steve Bannon and Marjorie Green - might wish to decide exactly the opposite of whatever they are proposing.
In an interesting interview that I heard recently, a former Israel ambassador indicated that even the JOCPA (the nuclear deal with Iran that President Obama had signed) was only going to buy the world some additional time - and still would have permitted Iran to develop a nuclear weapon eventually. In other words, even those on Obama's team recognized that the JOCPA was a very flawed deal. However, even through Trump ripped up the deal during his first term - Trump did not replace it with anything - nor did he attack Iran militarily. So he left Iran sailing towards a nuclear bomb, at a much faster clip - and now had to deal with the consequences of that policy. Granted in the intervening period - President Biden took no discernible action on this file. In short, there is enough blame to go around between Obama, Trump and Biden, but President Trump was now the one to take the courageous decision to destroy these plants (or at least try to).
What Now?
At this point, we are waiting to see how Iran will respond to the U.S. attacks. Iran sent a barrage of missiles to Israel just hours after the U.S. attacks and some of them landed in Israel, causing significant civilian damage and injuring many Israelis.
But Iran and its leadership have a choice to make at this point. If they decide to "go all in" in a war with the U.S. - that is almost certainly going to end in disaster for this Iranian regime. They have been weakened militarily by Israel's attacks since June 13, 2025 and, according to most reports, they do not seem to be in any position to take on the U.S. Army. However, since at least some of the leadership are fanatic, suicidal and not necessarily realistic about their prospects, they may decide to go this route and hope that other countries join or assist them (Russia? North Korea? China? others). In my view, this would be a dangerous escalation but is really not likely to end well for Iran. I would hope that someone will deliver this prognosis to the Iranian Supreme Leader - but he may not be in any mood to hear it - or to listen to it. This might draw President Trump and the U.S. into a war to a greater extent than they had hoped, but I believe that it will be, primarily, a campaign of aerial and missile attacks. Hopefully, the Iranians will not be able to produce and deploy a nuclear weapon during the course of this fight.
A second option is for the Iranians to effectively "surrender" to the U.S. and agree to U.S. terms for a cease fire. I believe that this is highly unlikely at this point. It would result in the disintegration of the Iranian regime and it would be humiliating. It is apparently not a consideration for the current Iranian leadership even if things continue to deteriorate.
A third option would be, what I would call - a hybrid. It is possible, in my view, that Iran will attack some U.S. bases but to a limited extent - with relatively minimal damage. This would allow Iran to claim (to the Iranian public and the world) that it had responded to the U.S. attack with "devastating results" and was now ready to negotiate. If the U.S. were to decide that it could "live with" the damage caused - this might be a way out for both parties. If the Iranians go too far and actually damage U.S. interests significantly - they will be met by a massive response from the U.S. Nevertheless, I think that this is the most realistic possibility for a quick end to the situation, provided that the Iranians are willing to end their nuclear program and agree to U.S. inspections as part of a deal.
One Israel-based commentator noted earlier today that the Iranians made exactly this type of "least worst" deal when ending the Iran-Iraq war. They publicly characterized it as drinking a cup of poison to save the regime.
If Iran does not find a way to negotiate a resolution, the continuation of the current war is likely to devastate Iran and bring about the downfall of the current regime. The difficulty then becomes figuring out how Iran can govern itself without descending into a chaotic civil war or anarchy.
It is possible that other players will become involved and will threaten the use of nuclear weapons - and try to cause this conflict to spread. I believe that the chances of this happening are relatively low since I do not believe that Russia or China want to go "all in" at this point - to hope a fanatical Iranian regime - despite the lip service that they might pay to that possibility.
Situation in Israel
As of last night, the Homefront Command in Israel announced the full emergency measures were in place. No gatherings of more than 30 people, schools and universities closed - and most establishments closed other than those designated as "essential."
The airport was officially closed last night - however, it was reopened (partially today).
For Israelis looking to get back to Israel - and yes, many thousands are, some Israeli airlines have organized "rescue" flights. El Al, Arkia and Israir are asking people to sign up and are prioritizing them according to various factors including any humanitarian issues (need for medicine or medical treatment, family situation etc.,.) In English, these flights are being called "repatriation flights" but in Hebrew the word is "chilutz" which means rescue.
This means that I could agree to be "rescued" from Canada and make my way back to Israel by flying from one of several destinations chosen by El Al - including Rome, Larnaca (Cyprus), Athens and some yet to be named U.S. cities - likely New York and Los Angeles. However, this would, of course, be a one-way flight. Given that I have certain work commitments in July, including some trials that I am running in Toronto, it would be risky to go back to Israel indefinitely at this time (irrespective of the potential physical danger, which I am less worried about).
Some Israelis are coming back to Israel by boat. For example, I have some family members who are getting on a cruise ship from Cyprus and taking a 15 hour cruise back to Israel. That actually sounds like fun - as long as the accompanying navy destroyer can protect the cruise ship from any incoming missiles.
It would probably seem surreal to be on a cruise ship, complete with its fine dining restaurants, gambling rooms, swimming pools and perhaps even some entertainment, while on the way back to Israel to face the uncertainty of nightly missile attacks.
For those looking to leave Israel, the options are limited. I read that El Al would now be departing with a maximum of 50 passengers on a range of flights though I am not sure how easy it is to get a seat on these flights. Some birthright groups and others left Israel on those same cruise ships - to Cyprus - and picked up flights from there
The magnanimous and considerate Canadian government has offered to provide a free bus ride for Canadians from Tel-Aviv to Amman. From Amman, they are "on their own" though the Canadian government will try to help people find flights from Amman to other locations and eventually back to Canada. I spoke to someone yesterday at Synagogue - who told me that their family member took one of these rides to Amman and has now been told that the next available flight out is July 3rd, 2025 - or about 11 days from now.
My understanding is that Amman does not have the types of shelters that Israel does and his being hit with occasional pieces of missiles that have been shot down. As well, the Jordanian airport has been opening and closing depending on the situation. Even though Jordanian falafel is apparently quite good, I would rather wait in Israel and take my chances in the Israeli shelters. But maybe that's just me...
In contrast to Canada, by the way, the U.S. has been organizing flights for U.S. citizens from Tel-Aviv to Athens. Americans can register with the U.S. government and wait to be notified of an available flight. Beats a bus ride to Amman, in my view, even though the falafels at the Ben Gurion airport (if any of the food places are open) might not be as tasty as those in Amman. (Though in Israel they will be Kosher).
Religion
I couldn't finish this blog without mentioning at least 2 or 3 religious references.
For one thing, many observant Jews were convinced that the U.S. attack would take place this week to coincide with the dates in the Biblical story of Purim on which King Achashverosh decreed that the Jewish of Shushan (modern day Iran) and surrounding areas could defend themselves with arms against those who were seeking to kill them. Okay the date did not work out exactly as planned - but considering that the operation was planned months ago for 6-13 - this may well have been a consideration.
I am part of a social media group that discusses "leining issues" (issues relating to the reading of the weekly Torah portion. There was a whole discussion - about what happens if a forced synagogue closure causes a shul to skip the weekly Torah reading. Does it do a double reading the next week? Apparently, the halachic answer was that you read the entire previous week's portion as the first aliyah, combined with the first aliyah for that week. That is a lot of Torah reading! Everyone has their own priority list of issues to consider when dealing with ongoing missile barrages. (Other Israelis are preoccupied with which items they need to keep in the safe room - in ready-to-go bags - in case the building is hit by a missile and destroyed).
Lastly - I note that Prime Minister Netanyahu found quite a healthy dose of religion over the past few days. Just now, I heard him explaining that he wrapped himself in a Tallith, visited the Kotel and said "Shema Yisrael" just before authorizing the Israeli operation. He said that he repeated this gestures in thanks yesterday after hearing from President Trump that the operation had been a success. This is fascinating coming from an avowedly secular Prime Minister. Perhaps the more cynical among us might wonder if he is trying to appeal to his Orthodox supporters to bolster his support - but surely Prime Minister Netanyahu could not be that cynical...could he? I leave that to you to determine.
Conclusion
We remain hopeful that our planned family wedding for September 4th will go ahead along with all of the other events including the aufruf, Hina and Shabbat dinner. Hopefully, there will be some kind of deal in place - with Iran and Hamas, the war will be over and the hostages will be back home. And I hope that I will have been able to go back and forth at least once or twice between now and then.
There are many things that I have not covered in this blog - just too much going on - so I will save some material for next time. In the meantime, I am hoping and praying for the safety of our Israeli armed forces in carrying out their operations, for the safety of Israeli civilians all over Israel (Jewish, Christian and Muslim - all of whom have been targeted by Iranian missiles), for the safe return of the hostages and an end to the Gaza war and for an end to this war that results in many years of peace in the Middle East. Shavua Tov.
